Posted By Daniel W. Drezner Share

The great Bono-as-columnist experiment has started at the New York Times

And, I have to say, his debut column is a smashing success. In just his first effort, Bono has already managed to combine the worst tropes of Thomas Friedman and Maureen Dowd and fuse them together into some new alchemy of awfulness. At this rate, by March, he will have already progressed to Advanced Op-ed Babble, a state of nirvana heretofore only achieved by A.M. Rosenthal's "On My Mind".

Contest to readers: read Bono's column and, in 20 words or less, explain its theme in the comments. Here's my effort: 

Did you know that I knew Frank Sinatra?" 

 

DECISIVEMOMENT

4:45 PM ET

January 11, 2009

"I'm still me, I'm still

"I'm still me, I'm still cool, and I'm still not a tax exile. Honest!"

 

BILL R

4:46 PM ET

January 11, 2009

"Contest to readers: read

"Contest to readers: read Bono's column". I lose. I couldn't even make it past the first paragraph. Darn!

 

GLENNCHUCK

5:15 PM ET

January 11, 2009

Bono--the great--writer

Not only am I a worldwide star and humanitarian, I am--as of now--a great writer--a point I slam home inside--a great many--em dashes. And abrupt. Sentences. Plus, I still drink in Irish pubs--thus--I am cool. Bono cool.

 

NAGEE76

7:32 PM ET

January 11, 2009

I tried !

I tried to read it... but his op-ed writing skills are not as good as his song writing...to put it mildly.

 

DJ_83

7:43 PM ET

January 11, 2009

Drivel

"You are wasting five minutes of your business life, your love life, your life life."

 

KHOMOTSO

2:00 AM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono-ku

I am cool like Frank.
But Frank is cooler, though I
Cool for grasping Frank.

The Frank of Frank. I.

 

WASHBOARDALEX

10:29 AM ET

January 12, 2009

HEY EVERYONE,

LOOK AT MY HYPERBOLE. EVERYONE! MY HYPERBOLE!!!

 

MEHMET

1:32 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono's article "contest"

Bono shares in the NYT his unique experience of friendship with the singer of "NY,NY" which, among other things, taught him humility over hubris..

 

OBIE

2:18 PM ET

January 12, 2009

A story...

A sultry vision, a dream. Watch me turn it--me, Bono!--into a crappy metaphor about America.

 

APPALLED MODERATE

2:53 PM ET

January 12, 2009

He Did It His Way

I did my column my way. Though I did it that way while soaked in overindulged in whine (er, wine).

 

PAT FROST

4:59 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono

I am famous. I met another famous person. Read my incoherent thoughts on said other famous person. I am famous.

 

TREVOSHEA

6:07 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Congratulations, all of you,

Congratulations, all of you, on your masturbatory comments thread. It is greatly amusing to see that even professors and readers of Foreign Policy can be completely unable to understand prose. I'll help you out!

Bono was writing about Frank Sinatra, life, innocence, and art. His target audience? NOT YOU.

Why are you even talking about this on Foreign Policy? Do you really think the purpose of celebrity advocacy is to target people who read Foreign Policy? Do you really think Bono was writing a column about anything that is relevant to Foreign Policy?

Hey, Drezner, if you want to make fun of shit that has nothing to do with foreign policy, go get some space on Blogger.

 

APPALLED MODERATE

6:58 PM ET

January 12, 2009

But What Did He Say, Trevoshea?

Trvoshea:

I agree Drezner's likening Bono's column to the well-travelled cliche mongering of Friedman was a bit unfair. Old Tommy Friedman has got to be feeling a bit crowded and hot by this comment.

Because Bono's column resembles nothing more than the sort of rock critic blovation one might find in an alternative weekly in a medium sized American city. (You know, the free newspaper with all the music reviews and sex ads that thinks it's as good as the Village Voice?) There's been a lot said about Sinatra (and Miles Davis, for that matter), and Bono's gloss is not profound, revealing new information, or coherent.

Sounds ripe for mockery to me,

 

WILL IN STL

8:43 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Isn't it ironic that I

Isn't it ironic that I attempt to overcompensate for my height with abrupt sentences?

 

OMANIPHIL

12:01 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Wannabe Mitch Albom

Wannabe Mitch Albom

 

MACK THE KNIFE

8:47 PM ET

January 12, 2009

When I type

words appear on the screen. Empty screen. Filled with words like liquor in a glass. Ready for a toast. Toast words.

 

BECKYLOOO

9:09 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Mmmmmmm...

...beer.

 

UNCLESMEDLEY

9:57 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono

"Pedantic, supercilious bloggers don't understand how interpretive skills generally gain in the course of a life well abused. Fuck 'em."

 

WAYNSKI77

9:31 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono

I know many adjectives and I shall use them all.

 

UNCLESMEDLEY

10:10 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Seriously

The abject snobbery about Bono's column is a wee bit pitiful. Does anyone suppose that he submitted this piece in the hopes of publication? Of course not. He's a celebrity rock star with a reasonably impressive extra-curricular CV.

The New York Times was looking for -- nay, desperate for --

an attraction and, apparently, they succeeded. Danny D and his 20-Word Wonders come across as resentful--not so much of the lackadaisical, flow-of-conscious style, as of the fact that he got the gig and wasn't even looking for it. Do you think Bono needs the Times? Really? For what?

I'm no big fan of Bono. U2's alright, I suppose. I liked Joshua Tree. But I've been more impressed by the fact that this no-account Irish guy has become one of the most well-known people in the world--and not in the Paris Hiltonish sense, but more in the Bill Gates/Al Gore mold.

Accordingly, Like Bill and AL--and Frank Sinatra--he now gets to do whatever he wants. And all these talented, smart people on this comment thread have to keep their day jobs.

Ain't life a b****?

 

NIGORB

9:55 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono

Fool most world leaders, most of the time - check.
NYT readers - not so much.

 

UNCLESMEDLEY

10:12 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Perfect

So true. Readers of the NY Times are the most smartest people in the whole wide world.

 

MACGREINER

12:13 AM ET

January 13, 2009

I agree, the writing doesn't

I agree, the writing doesn't make for flowing prose, but your suggestion about the readers of the NYT trumps any of Bono’s unsubstantiated claims or bloated self-congratulatory rhetoric.

 

WATERBOARDMEPLZ

10:18 PM ET

January 12, 2009

bono

sophomoric suede vinegar cool.
yessss. oh yesss.

[soft jazz in background]

 

DUBIOUS

11:46 PM ET

January 12, 2009

Bono

I'm Irish. I'm smart. And I'm almost as pretentious as Dick Cavett.

 

OHIOMEISTER

12:05 AM ET

January 13, 2009

Lame

I'm referring to Dan and those leaving comments, not Bono. I thought his story about Frank Sinatra was interesting and amusing, and I don't see the harm in using Frank's life and My Way, one of his well known songs, to speak metaphorically about the current American moment.

Besides, who would possibly want to read something written by one of the best known humanitarians in the world when you can leave snarky comments on an obscure FP blog?? Lucky me, I got to do both!

 

CHRISTOPHERG

12:21 AM ET

January 13, 2009

Bushian slip

And he referred to America where in the article

 

CHRISTOPHERG

12:20 AM ET

January 13, 2009

Giving it an honest shot

We did it My Way. Didn't all go well.
We'll keep singing it, ever deeper, till it's time to go.

 

SAMDUPONT

1:21 AM ET

January 13, 2009

in explanation, i can't do

in explanation, i can't do better than to quote his own words:

"This singer, i.e. me, is in a puddle."

 

HARRY HALLER

1:30 AM ET

January 13, 2009

The Gist of Bono's Op-Ed

"In case you didn't know it before, I'm a tool."

 

GANCELIN

2:11 AM ET

January 13, 2009

I Bono am of the pub. I Bono

I Bono am of the pub. I Bono Still live in Dub. I Bono did sing with Frank. Yellow painting.

 

MATTHEW GOGGINS

10:38 AM ET

January 13, 2009

"Regrets, I've had a few..."

We need to remember to keep the romance of life alive in times of loss and uncertainty. Thanks, Frank.

[ I thought Bono's debut was super, very strong. His topic was timely and the presentation was thoughtful and heartfelt. I look forward to reading his next Op-Ed. ]

 

12INCHESOFHANGINGDEATH

1:08 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Yes Thoughtful

And weird and goofy and full of pretension.

But hey, he's BOBO...er...BONO so we must listen.

Yes listen. Like a breath of air on the breeze of life.

 

MATTHEW GOGGINS

7:19 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Would you like to explain "pretentious" a bit more?

Thank you for your reaction, I have a few questions/comments.

When you're a rock star and an international celebrity, is silence the only way to avoid sounding self-important?

Is there anything the man could have written that would not have been pretentious in your view?

Bono's Op-Ed made me think about Sinatra and his music; about the passage of time and the meaning of individualism. It brought back some forgotten memories and put them in a new context.

When you claim Bono's writing is pretentious, are you referring to the objective hard copy that he produced, or are you referring to a subjective reaction that is provoked in some readers but not in others? And if pretentiousness can only be determined by the reactions it provokes, then what percentage of turned-off readers would demonstrate Bono's: 75%, 10%, 50% plus one?

 

MR. BINGLEY

2:30 PM ET

January 13, 2009

"Does this column make me

"Does this column make me look fat?"

 

AGENTYX

2:34 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Bono's Editorial

"I'm drunk, but did you know the failure of the new Irish economy is like Frank Sinatra's singing careers... somehow?"

 

RIGHTWINGCONSPIRACY

2:47 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Bono's blather

I've written 750 words ... still need 250 more.

 

PEACHBOY

3:13 PM ET

January 13, 2009

I'll take a shot

First Attempt:

Frank Sinatra's music is unsentimental, original, and complex, and provides meaningful lessons appropriate for the times.

Second Attempt:

I know Frank Sinatra and you don't.

 

SARAH ROLPH

3:20 PM ET

January 13, 2009

i think it's a nice piece

I enjoyed Bono's column. Sure, it rambles a bit, but I think he pulls it off pretty well.

I think the theme of the piece is: be yourself, roll with the punches, there will be good times and bad times and you won't always know which is which.

Seems like a nice theme for a New Year's piece, and I enjoyed the personal tidbits about Sinatra.

I would venture that his writing is a lot better than most of our singing.

 

MANDY CAT

3:57 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Bono Column in 20 Words

Me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me me!

 

123RH456

4:39 PM ET

January 13, 2009

My attempt: "If you wonder

My attempt: "If you wonder why the NY Times is failing, just read my new column."

 

RACHEL1700

7:54 PM ET

January 13, 2009

Bono 20 words or less

I AM. Ah--Dark and stormy! Knight!!

 

KEVINT

9:35 PM ET

January 13, 2009

 

SPIRALFORWARD

6:40 AM ET

January 15, 2009

funny...

what i read was about the complicated facets of sentamentality in the midst of purported change, using sinatra and booze as illustrative vehicles.
my bad.

 

Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

Read More