Monday, January 26, 2009 - 12:25 AM
It's Oscar season, and the general consensus seems to the that the actual Oscar nominations mostly suck eggs.
So, playing off this Tyler Cowen post about economists in the movies, I began to wonder if the problem is that movies need to have more political scientists in them. After all, how many political scientists -- as opposed to politicians -- have been portrayed on film?
The answer appears to be "not many." Some of the people on Tyler's list -- Carl Kaysen in Girl, Interrupted, for example -- qualify for political science as well. Independent of Cowen's list, however, I could only think of three movie characters who were clearly identified as political scientists:
This is pretty thin gruel.
Of course, that could be because our jobs are boring, or it could be because political scientists are "incredibly uncool, socially inept, and about as socially connected to high society as Gomer Pyle on crystal meth."
Question to readers: I'm sure that there are poli sci characters in movies that I am missing. Who are they?
I don't know of any of the top of my head; however, I'm sure films like Primary Colors, Bob Roberts, The Contender, The Manchurian Candidate, Lions for Lambs, and anything by Aaron Sorkin are saturated with self-identified political scientists.
It's a pity none of these fictional brethren are memorable.
I can't remember whether the movie is clear about what discipline he's from... but he smacks of a RAND corp. game theorist, which is close enough for me!
isn't Jack Ryan an ex-marine who became a CIA analyst? (hunt for red october). doesn't he count?
I could have sworn it said in the beginning of the Hunt for the Red October that he teaches in the War Studies Department at King's College London... hence his having to travel to Washington from London. I don't have the book with me so I can't check.
Playing Prof. Groeteschele (based on Herman Kahn). Not the most flattering portrayal of the science, but hey it's a mention.
EDIT: Whoops, it was in the linked post.
I' pretty sure Dr. Malley in "Lions for Lambs" is a professor of political science...
Dr. Elizabeth Weir from the Sci-fi TV shows Stargate SG1 and Stargate Atlantis is a political scientist, with a PhD and was a professor at Georgetown. Can't think of any movie characters though.
In the best political film ever made, The Candidate, I suspect that the befuddled, inept academic pictured in the group gathering when -- I believe it was -- Natalie Wood stopped by Robert Redford's campaign office was a political scientist.
Nicole Kidman played Dr. Julia Kelly, a nuclear expert, in the film The Peacemaker. {Her expertise seems to be more political/terrorism than actually nuclear.)
That Superbad Arlington Road Movie
Jeff Bridges played a political scientist in Arlington Road. I'm pretty sure that neither Bridges nor anyone involved in the production of that movie ever sat in a poli- sci classroom however, judging from the thoroughly unconvincing performance.
He plays a specialist in terrorism and at one point in a lecture he asks his students how random violence "makes them feel."
How does terrorism make you feel? What the hell kind of question is that?
According to a recent post on Crooked Timbers http://crookedtimber.org/2009/01/22/hotties-and-notties/ we are relatively hot, so that may not explain it. A couple old political science majors, Ronald D. Moore and David Eick, are the creators of the great, even cinematic TV series Battlestar Galactica.
Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Read More
(13)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE