Thursday, April 23, 2009 - 2:23 PM
One could quibble a fair amount with Steve Walt's post about countries punching above and below their weight in world politics (if North Korea and Israel are influential because of their ability to make mischief, then Pakistan and Iran are punching way above their weight class).
However, Walt's inclusion of Japan as a country that has less influence than it should is beyond dispute. And the New York Times' Hiroko Tabuchi has a story today that provides another data point for this categorization. Apparently, Japan is trying to kick out some of the the paltry number of immigrants it currently has in its territory:
Rita Yamaoka, a mother of three who immigrated from Brazil, recently lost her factory job here. Now, Japan has made her an offer she might not be able to refuse.
The government will pay thousands of dollars to fly Mrs. Yamaoka; her husband, who is a Brazilian citizen of Japanese descent; and their family back to Brazil. But in exchange, Mrs. Yamaoka and her husband must agree never to seek to work in Japan again....
Japan’s offer, extended to hundreds of thousands of blue-collar Latin American immigrants, is part of a new drive to encourage them to leave this recession-racked country. So far, at least 100 workers and their families have agreed to leave, Japanese officials said.
But critics denounce the program as shortsighted, inhumane and a threat to what little progress Japan has made in opening its economy to foreign workers.
“It’s a disgrace. It’s cold-hearted,” said Hidenori Sakanaka, director of the Japan Immigration Policy Institute, an independent research organization.
“And Japan is kicking itself in the foot,” he added. “We might be in a recession now, but it’s clear it doesn’t have a future without workers from overseas.”
That last quote is pretty much accurate -- which is why this is such a puzzling maneuver.
In terms of demographics, about the best thing one can say about Japan is that at least it's not as bad as Russia.
Isn't the elephant in the room that the overachievers tend to have nuclear weapons or are developing them?
And the underachievers tend to be democracies.
I didn't find that much to quibble over with Walt
I don't think there's any real competition for Israel as chief mischief maker. Whether it's their President screwing over our President in his overtures to Iran. (even some Israel Lobby guy got in the act with his very own 'mischievous with love to Iran video'). It must really irk some that despite bestest attempts to create a narrative in their own unquestionable image, the media have failed to inform and convince the whole wide world who the real "problem" actually is. It was Iraq, now it's Iran. I'd still like to know why Israel was so mixed up in "democratising" Georgia. Gee, what a shame Mr Saakisivili came badly unstuck. It seems there is no end to Israel and it's Lobby's propensity for mischief.
Damn that Mr Walt for asking questions about American interests. The upstart!
It's an incredibly short-sighted move on Japan's part, since they will ultimately need those workers if they don't want to end up with one retired elderly person for every two workers by 2050. But then, I guess that was off the agenda anyways, considering how the Japanese treat these guys (Brazilians of Japanese descent), as well as Korean immigrants (they're held out for generations after their arrival).
But who knows? At the very least, this will keep funding for robotics very high.
You can only pity the Russians on this issue. They're losing something like 700,000 people a year, and if they ever get economically integrated with Europe to the point where significantly greater migration is possible, then it will be even worse.
At least, that's what I've heard from some Russians. I asked one Russian guy what would happen if Russia was ever admitted into the EU - he basically said that all of the young people in Russia would be headed west.
Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Read More
(3)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE