Posted By Daniel W. Drezner Share

As a resident of the Boston area for the past few years, I'm been very grateful for the Golden Age of Sport that has descended upon Beantown for the past decade.  The three Super Bowls, two World Series, an NBA World Championship, and countless other exciting playoff runs (next year, Bruins!) have been nothing short of exhilirating. 

They do not, however, make Boston the greatest sports city in North America -- according to one metric, we're only #2.  Lee Sigelman alerts me to this Toronto Star effort to determine the best sports city in North America north of the Rio Grande.  Their answer might surprise you:   

For its relatively diminutive size and low Midwestern profile, Indianapolis is a sporting powerhouse. The city's National Football League Colts and National Basketball Association Pacers have logged wins 66 per cent of the time since 2000.

Perhaps best known for the Indianapolis 500, the city is home to the NCAA and many of its major tournaments, has hosted more than 400 national and international championships since 1980 and will welcome the Super Bowl in 2012.

They built this city on sports, says Bill Benner, a former sports columnist at The Indianapolis Star. "Indianapolis, beginning about 30 years ago, used sports ... as an economic development strategy. Using sports as the cornerstone played out beyond anyone's imagination."

With sporting success has come civic pride, says Stephanie Parks, one-quarter of a diehard Indianapolis family of sports fanatics.

"Being a sports capital is closely tied with the city's sense of self," says the mother of two athletic children seeking to follow in the footsteps of their pro heroes. "We own two businesses and during football season we have `blue Friday,' wherein everyone is to dress up in blue or wear their Colts shirts."

The Star calculated this by calculating, "percentages among professional sports teams in 37 North American cities since 2000" plus "bonus points for making the playoffs or winning a championship."  I'll let my readers quibble about the validity of this measure. 

No, what piques my interest is whether there's a way to go global with this kind of question.  If one factored in other team sports -- soccer non-American football, rugby, cricket -- which metropolis could claim the crown of the Greatest Sporting City in the World?

 

TMORGAN

6:16 PM ET

May 22, 2009

Different set-ups

Well London has lots of non-American football clubs, a couple of which have been quite good historically. I don't know if internationally there are the same number of sports that draw the same attention. But Boston is up there so far because- all major American sports are represented, all of the teams have had recent success, and such a large proportion of the population is emotionally invested. Is there any other city where four teams in different sports can sell 17k tickets to every game in the same season? Then again maybe we Red Sox fans need to start writing songs for every hitter like baseball fans in Japan and Korea.

 

TOM HARRISON

12:57 AM ET

May 23, 2009

Melbourne - Australia's Sporting Capital

Melbourne's reputation is linked to sport, given that it is able to hold so many major sporting events for a relatively small city (3 million people). The annual AFL Grand Final attracts 100,000 people to watch the game as opposed to just enjoying the surrounding hype of a Superbowl, and this is after 22 weeks of games that include 10 teams from Mebourne in a national competition of 16. The weekly hype of games means that no one can go without an allegiance or avoid discussing the matches - stories about the players or the league regularly lead the news or hit front pages of newspapers, not just the front of the sports section. There is also the Melbourne Cup, which has far greater global reach as a horse race than the Kentucky Derby, and the Australian Open tennis as well as an annual Grand Prix.

 

MONEYINABOX

5:24 AM ET

May 23, 2009

Greater London hands down.

Greater London hands down. They have more football teams then they know what to do with (Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham, Fulham, West Ham, Watford, Milwall, QPR, etc.), rugby, ice hockey, an annual sold-out NFL game, Wimbledon, the upcoming Olympics, among others. While they may lack in popular North American sports, they more than make up for it in terms of the sports the rest of the world likes to watch.

 

G

7:09 AM ET

May 24, 2009

hate to say it - toronto

I'm not from there, but must give credit where credit is due. How many sports and/or teams - as opposed to a dozen in one sport - allow you to qualify for this survey?

Not one but two of the major north american leagues are trying (or not) to have another team placed in the GTO area.

Maple Leafs - 2nd in (Ice) hockey champs
Argos - CFL (look it up)
Blue Jays - MLB champs twice in the early 90's
Raptors - NBA

This list of four doesn't begin to mention the legions of junior and semi-pro teams that oppurate in the Toronto area in several leagues.

If the Bills want to move there...must be the best sports town...or the best sports town with a glutton for punishment.

 

G

7:16 AM ET

May 24, 2009

I forgot to mention TFC in

I forgot to mention TFC in the MSL - along with the songs the fan club has written about some of there players...

 

RENE BENTHIEN

8:27 AM ET

May 24, 2009

I second Melbourne

As a Sydney-sider I hate saying this, but Melbourne is easily the most sports-involved city I can think of.

In addition to the Melbourne Cup, the AFL domination, the Austrlian Open Tennis and the Grand Prix, Victoria also won the Sheffield Shield in cricket this year. The MCG, the heart of Australian cricket, has been voted as one of the seven wonders of the sporting world.

Also in A-league soccer Melbourne completed the treble last season after winning the Grand Final, winning the Premiership, and winning the Pre-season cup. And Victory has easily been the most successful team in the short history of the A-league so far.

 

BIRD YOSHIKAWA

3:35 PM ET

May 26, 2009

I second Boston.

I don't know enough about Melbourne. London is a good pick. But Indianapolis? Toronto???

The Boston Celtics are the greatest NBA franchise (or tied with LA), the Red Sox have a "better than fiction" history, the Bruins had Bobby Orr, the Patriots were THE football team of the last decade, there's the Boston Marathon, and 22 universities (remember Doug Flutie?), not to mention some of the fiercest high school hockey. Don't forget The Country Club in Brookline, as well as Essex (the oldest golf course in the country). The mix of working class heros and all those students makes for a magical sports town. I remember chasing baseballs that cleared the Green Monster and I remember barely seeing the court for all the smoke in the Boston Garden...

 

Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

Read More