Your humble blogger is fully aware that everyone and their mother has been blogging and writing about the big Obama speech from yesterday.  Why, you might ask, have I been silent?  [I might, I might indeed!--ed.]

It's a combination of four things:

  1. Like Mark Lynch, I want to wait and see what the longer-term effects are -- if any.  By longer term, we're talking past the six-hour window that bloggers would consider as long-term.
  2. There are plenty of FP bloggers who can write about this to any ideological flavor.  So I'm free-riding off of them rather than write about a subject on which writing persuades no one and brings nothing but loopiness to the comments section.
  3. [He's waaaay behind on some other writing assignments!!--ed.]  You weren't supposed to say that out loud.
  4. Superficial cultural gadfly that I am, the thing that caught my attention this AM was not the reax to the Obama speech, but A.O. Scott's devastating evisceration of Sam Mendes' new movie Away We Go (though I do grant that the trailer looks amusing).  In this paragraph, Scott articulates for me the response I always have to Mendes' work: 

To observe that they inhabit no recognizable American social reality is only to say that this is a film by Sam Mendes, a literary tourist from Britain who has missed the point every time he has crossed the ocean. The vague, secondhand ideas about the blight of the suburbs that sloshed around American Beauty and Revolutionary Road are now complemented by an equally incoherent set of notions about the open road, the pioneer spirit, the idealism of youth.

Clearly, Sam Mendes is not the film equivalent of de Tocqueville.  This, of course, leads to a vital film question:  who is the cinematic equivalent of Alexis de Tocqueville?

 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

STATSGURU

4:13 PM ET

June 5, 2009

Cinema

Frank Capra? :-)

 

BENDER

3:48 AM ET

June 6, 2009

de tocqueville

Tough but good question.........

Wim Wenders' Paris, Texas came to mind as a very american film made by a foreigner, although that may just be because it's a favorite of mine--Sam Shepard wrote the screenplay, which makes this even more tenuous an analogy.

Perhaps David Lynch is the better answer, given that he is almost certainly an alien and also possessed with great insight into the American condition--although his lens is a bit obscured/colored by his own darkness (Straight Story being the exception).

that's all i got off the top of my head

 

MARK P. HAVERKAMP

1:05 PM ET

June 6, 2009

The Obama presidency will be

The Obama presidency will be an era of giving speeches.

 

BRETT

9:21 AM ET

June 7, 2009

The speech sounded nice when

The speech sounded nice when read (I hate listening to speeches), particularly the bit on settlements, but to be honest, I'd rather have less speeches. A lot less speeches. Maybe no speeches for a while.

How about we just implement a good policy in the Middle East, then talk about it after we've done it?

Sorry. I like Obama, I really do, but he talks too much.

 

DJ_83

2:08 PM ET

June 8, 2009

His fans (who seem

His fans (who seem concentrated along the Riviera) would say Lars von Trier. Wenders is good, but he only had one movie.

I'd say Ang Lee comes close(although Alistair Cooke's not bad), with the Ice Storm and Brokeback Mountain. Keeping my fingers crossed about Taking Woodstock.

 

MR PUNCH

6:21 PM ET

June 8, 2009

plus he married Candice Bergen

Oh come on. Pretty Baby? Atlantic City? Crackers? Well, they may have been before your time – but so was Democracy in America, which utterly lacks a scantily-clad Susan Sarandon shucking oysters. Louis Malle is the Tocqueville of cinema.

 

Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

Read More