Never say that press conferences are meaningless

Mon, 11/02/2009 - 4:34pm

Your humble blogger's all-time favorite historian, Mary Elise Sarotte, has just published her magnum opus, 1989: The Struggle to Create Post-Cold War Europe, about the fall of the Brelin Wall and the year of diplomacy that led to a renunified Germany ensconced within NATO and the European Union. 

In the Washington Post yesterday, Sarotte recounts the precise manner in which the Berlin Wall fell.  Turns out that a botched press conference played a rather significant role:   

That night at 6, Guenter Schabowski, a member of the East German Politburo who served as its spokesman, was scheduled to hold a news conference. Shortly before it began, he received a piece of paper with an update on the regulations and a suggestion that he mention them publicly. He had not been involved in discussions about the rules and did not have time to read the document carefully before starting.

His hour-long news conference was so tedious that Tom Brokaw, who was there, remembered being "bored." But in the final minutes, an Italian journalist's question about travel spurred Schabowski's memory. He tried to summarize the new regulations but became confused, and his sentences trailed off. "Anyway, today, as far as I know, a decision has been made," he said. "It is a recommendation of the Politburo that has been taken up, that one should from the draft of a travel law, take out a passage. . ."

Among the long-winded clauses, some snippets leapt out: "exit via border crossings" and "possible for every citizen."

Suddenly, every journalist in the room had questions. "When does that go into force?" shouted one. "Immediately?" shouted another. Rattled and mumbling to himself, Schabowski flipped through his papers until he uttered the phrase: "Immediately, right away."

It felt as if "a signal had come from outer space and electrified the room," Brokaw recalled. Some wire journalists rushed out to file reports, but the questions kept coming, among them: "What will happen to the Berlin Wall now?"

Alarmed about what was unfolding, Schabowski concluded with more muddled responses: "The question of travel, of the permeability therefore of the wall from our side, does not yet answer, exclusively, the question of the meaning, of this, let me say it this way, fortified border." Furthermore, "the debate over these questions could be positively influenced if the Federal Republic [of West Germany] and if NATO would commit themselves to and carry out disarmament."

As NATO was unlikely to disarm itself by breakfast, Schabowski clearly did not expect much to happen that night. But it was too late -- by 7:03 p.m., the wires were reporting that the Berlin Wall was open.

Read the rest of the article to find out what happened at Checkpoint Charlie and other guardposts across the Wall that evening.  And buy Sarotte's book to discover the rest of the story of German reunification. 



Advertisement

 

Dan's Book Club

Oooh! Love me a good Cold War history book. Thanks for this and for the recommendation!

Have you thought about a book club? Look what it did for Oprah... or what Oprah did for book clubs?... actually, maybe you shouldn't...

If memory serves the

If memory serves the gentleman had actually no idea that this was about to happen until moments before he gave the announcement.

True

But, as Sarotte recounts, the intended announcement was insignificant in its effects. It was the mangled wording at the press conference that causel all hell to break loose that night.

All hell might have broken loose inevitably, but that's a debate fo another day.

I agree, my point simply was

I agree, my point simply was that if the leadership had taken an hour to brief him properly they might have managed to buy a few more months. Just another reason for why policy makers should take a few lessons on the value of patience.

Journalists duel as to who asked him the question...

I love the Schabowski angle as one of those fabulous tiny but significant anecdotes that sometimes happen amidst greater events. There is an interesting "controversy" between journalists as to which one elicited the history-changing response from Schabowski. (http://www.germanhistoryblog.com/links-22-oct-2009/)

Regards,
Bill

On the other hand ...

George HW Bush threatened Iraq with invasion if Hussein did not meet certain conditions. Soviet diplomats raced to Baghdad, got Hussein's agreement to the conditions and observed that his force in Kuwait was physically starting to meet them. The kremlin awoke foreign correspondents at midnight to announce the good news in time for the US news cycle. The Bush white House assessed the report -- didn't challenge it -- announced a new set of conditions, more rigorous ones.

The Soviets worked their magic again, and as before, had it announced to the world through a midnight news conference. Bush said this was too late, he couldn't call off the invasion -- adding a remarkable chapter to commander-in-chiefhood. The Coalition then unleashed its might on a nation already committed to negotiated surrender and withdrawal in strict compliance with the Bush demands.

The outcome is usually described as a stunning US military victory, and must seem such to any person who didn't pay attention to those Moscow news conferences. Virtually everybody, huh?

Affairs as described above were thus reported in TIME magazine in a lengthy account by the chief Moscow negotiator. Washington made no reply to it.

Off The Wall

The significance of the fall of the Berlin Wall is, the triumph of Western Democracy over its rival, the Soviet Union. This means the world is free from oppression and the threat of a nuclear war. This means that western style Democracy is the dominant political philosophy throughout the world and will be supreme in the years ahead. Francis Fukuyama would say, 'The End of History'. Very well. We should proceed to China, North Korea, Cuba and Vietnam, and break their walls. Today, these states remain Communist and is surviving well on their own. Thus, there is no triumph over Communism by the fall of the Wall. What happened was, the unification of the European nation that was separated by imperial rivalries throughout most of their history. The collapse of the Wall brings about a new hope for creating a new power equation against the enemies of Western Democracy. Today, that should be China and Islam.