Posted By Daniel W. Drezner Share

The Christian Science Monitor's Yigal Schliefer reports on a less-than-productive meeting between Israel and Turkey:

A diplomatic spat is threatening to worsen Israel’s strained relations with Turkey, traditionally one of its most important allies in the region. The rift exposes growing Israeli frustration with Turkish leader Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who in a bid to increase Turkey’s regional standing has increasingly spoken out against Israel.

This latest crisis included a showdown at Israel’s Foreign Ministry, where Turkey’s ambassador was summoned to explain Mr. Erdogan’s recent harsh criticism, as well as a TV show that portrayed Israeli intelligence agents holding a woman and her baby hostage.

Breaking with diplomatic protocol, Israeli officials failed to include the customary Turkish flag on the table between them and the Turkish ambassador, whom they seated on a low couch. To rub it in, they instructed the press members in attendance to note that they were sitting in higher chairs and the usual diplomatic niceties were conspicuously absent.

“The message was, ‘We’ve had enough,’” says Ephraim Inbar, an expert on Turkey-Israel relations at Israel’s Bar-Ilan University. “Erdogan has taken things too far. It might have not been the best treatment for an ambassador, but it came from the gut. The signal is that we’re not going to take it anymore.” (emphasis added)

Yes, because heaping petty humiliations on another country will always shift their attitude in a more favorable direction.

Beyond Erdogan's statements -- which, from the Israeli perspective, are probably infuriating -- the proximate motivation for the meeting appears to be the depiction of Israelis on a 24-style show broadcast in Turkey.   Let me repeat that -- the Israeli Foreign Ministry is cheesed off about a Turkish television show. 

So, is this just Israeli overreaction?  Stupidity?  According to Ha'aretz's Barak Ravid, it's a bit more complicated than that

Senior officials in his own ministry say Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman is trying to foil the scheduled visit of Defense Minister Ehud Barak to Ankara following renewed tensions in relations between the two countries. Barak is scheduled to travel to Turkey on Sunday for an official visit in which he will meet with Turkey's defense and foreign ministers....

"There's a feeling Lieberman wants to heat things up before Barak's visit to Turkey," a senior Foreign Ministry official said. "Everything that took place yesterday was part of Lieberman's political agenda."

This raises a very troubling question:  what does it say about the state of Israel's body politic that Avigdor Lieberman thinks he can enhance his political position by snubbing one of the few semi-friendly countries in the region? 

UPDATE:  This was such a picayune slight that I'm sure it will all blow over.  Oh, wait....

 
Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

ZATHRAS

9:20 PM ET

January 12, 2010

I'm afraid it doesn't say

I'm afraid it doesn't say anything we didn't already know.

The current Israeli government includes representatives of the least reasonable factions in Israeli politics. They are not made less unreasonable by having their representatives included in the government, and they are if anything happier displaying their unreasonableness toward other Israelis than they are toward foreigners.

Lieberman here was pretty clearly trying to trip up Barak, whom he sees as a rival in the Cabinet. The Turks were just an excuse. Whether or not a gambit like this actually has much promise for Lieberman of enhancing his standing within Israel, it shows that he is utterly confident of his own base and therefore willing to take risks.

 

GPSADVOCATE

8:06 AM ET

January 19, 2010

I'd l'ke to believe that in

I'd l'ke to believe that in between this Israel-Turkey non sense thats been going on, somebody should see how ridiculous some of these politicians are. Their behavior is not of professionalism but grown adult version of schoolboys in a sand box.

With that said, the first thing I want to address:
1- why does a Country care so much about what was shown on a tv show? especially if its a fictional action show. Yeah so what if they showed mossad as kidnappers or whatever.
In one season of 24 (the famous keifer sutherland tv show) they portrayed turks as terrorists by having a character be a terrorist supplier. So what? big deal. As i said, sand box, this toy is mine not yours, im using the swing you cant type of issues.

2- Turkey and its recent political shifts:
Its no doubt that Turkey wants to expand its power in the region, especially considering its large population, economic growth, and military power. So, to grow your power what do you need to do? make peace with your neighbors, Im not a fan of Turkey being buddy buddy with IRan, but i dont think its necessarily THAT buddy buddy, I believe its just a way to keep Iran off their back for a while.

3- Why is israel always about gossip and whining about something?

I dont seem to understand why israel is constant crying or whining about something. Just because some people are anti-semetic doesnt mean that everyone is, they need to get over the segregating of themselves and be a part of GLOBALISATION. its not just about being the US's pawn in the middle east. I've noticed that Israelis love to talk about other peoples faults and wrongdoings rather than grow up and fix their own internal issues.

If anybody has seen the picture of that meeting between the Israeli and turkish diplomats, its pretty belittling to be honest. And that is such a childish way to deal with issues. How do these people get elected to where they are?

Me personally, im not a huge fan of Erdogan, his party is gradually shifting turkey to a more religious point. But as long as the Big money is held by the liberals, we still have a chance.

 

ZYH

4:47 AM ET

January 13, 2010

Tempest in a teapot

Whenever I see these kinds of issues getting extensive coverage in the Israeli media, I am relieved that there aren't more important things to worry about.

Also, this looks like a typical Libermanesque blunder. Actually, it seems to me that since the beginning of the current government, Barak serves as foreign minister in practice. Either because Liberman is not welcomed in many corners of the world or because Bibi doesn't trust him, Barak is doing a lot of traveling. Maybe that explains why Liberman is not happy with Barak.

Anyway, I thought that the Roger Cohen NYT piece on U.S.-China relations is much more interesting. I was hoping you'd comment on that.

 

MATTJS

10:50 AM ET

January 13, 2010

When a foreign PM accuses you of genocide

you can humiliate the ambassador of said country all you want.

 

GRANT

12:27 PM ET

January 13, 2010

We shouldn't discount the

We shouldn't discount the possibility that Turkey really is engaged (at least by the current party) in a long term shift away from Israel. While personally I would hope that it puts more pressure on Israel to have realistic ambitions for talks with the Palestinians, it also makes me worried about long term peace in the region.

 

CPOL

4:46 PM ET

January 13, 2010

leave it to a Lieberman to

leave it to a Lieberman to escalate a non-issue

 

SIR_MIXXALOT

6:55 PM ET

January 13, 2010

The current Israeli

The current Israeli government are terrorists.

Even Tzipi Livini's dad was a terrorist:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMGuYjt6CP8

 

Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.

Read More