Tuesday, April 27, 2010 - 1:27 PM

Is it just me, or is this less-than-exquisite timing for this particular roll-out?
Europe’s first Christian equity index was launched on Monday in response to increasing demand by investors for so-called ethical stocks in the wake of the financial crisis.
The Stoxx Europe Christian Index comprises 533 European companies that only derive revenues from sources approved “according to the values and principles of the Christian religion”.
BP, HSBC, Nestlé, Vodafone, Royal Dutch Shell and GlaxoSmithKline are among the companies in the index. Only groups that do not make money from pornography, weapons, tobacco, birth control and gambling are allowed to be listed.
A committee, which Stoxx says includes representatives of the Vatican, screens shares, which are drawn from the Stoxx Europe 600 Index (emphasis added).
Umm...... to state the obvious, I'm not sure this is the right moment for the Catholic Church to present itself as the arbiter of all things ethical. But hey, I'm a nonbeliever.
That said, I do wonder if there's an index fund that could be created that would be the inverse of this fund -- one that did nothing but profit from the seven deadly sins.
Readers already doomed to eternal damnation in hell with a mischevious streak are encouraged to suggest the appropriate companies to put into that fund in the comments.
As a fellow non-believer, I'm equally skeptical of the doctrines and institutional structures of all organized religions. Having said that, I don't see evidence supporting the suggestion that the Catholic Church is any more ethically challenged than other religions. Even on the narrow issue of pederasty, most mainstream religions have had such scandals. The Catholic Church is just an easier media and legal target because it's such a large, global institution.
In any event, ethical lapses shouldn't disqualify institutions from promoting ethical behavior. If anything, the fact that they continue to promote ethics should be encouraged as a way of countering the inevitable lapses.
The Catholic Church is a big player on the international scene. If it can use its power to help minimize the negative impact of some MNCs, good.
In fact, I see little difference between this effort and the ethical guidelines the Norwegian government uses to decide how it will invest its oil revenue. The Norwegian government also authorizes the hunting of whales and the clubbing of baby seals, but that doesn't mean we should mock its ethical investment efforts.
Shell? BP?
Isn't Shell responsible for atrocities where they operate? (Nigeria)... and a host of other vices (corruption etc.). Aren't oil companies responsible for pollution? BP's rig in the Gulf of Mexico is spewing oil, which will potentially reach the coast and ruin the ecosystem.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8090493.stm
Porn and birth control are not Christian
killing and environmental pollution though, are Christian ideals i guess.
I guess realistically there would be no company in this index if they all had to be up to Christian standards. Heck even the Catholic church itself isn't up to Christian standards.
Some of the companies on there are definitely not following many of the Christian Ethos. I would say that the actual list would be in the 0-5 amount, leaning towards the lower numbers. You don't get to be a large corporation by loving your enemies... My guess is this committee in some way has holdings in said stocks and are totally looking to gain off them more than they are looking for truly ethical companies.
Plus, with the Vatican behind it, you can be assured Altar Boys Inc. will be in the top 5 ethical companies to invest in...
Well, there's already a Vice Fund...
It may not be the correct names but..
wrath: Murdoch Media, dude chill Fox and the tabloids
greed: Lockheed Martin, any defence contractor will do
sloth: Porche, the 911 makes any church look progressive
pride: Apple, decent hardware and interface does not make divine
lust: Google, safe search off:
envy: Microsoft, see lust and pride
gluttony: Starbucks, double frappé with cinnamon and chocolate
The pissoff Vatican bonus lap: Zentropia(Lars von Trier), Durex,Playboy and Hustler
If memory serves there was a similar investment system (that could be still around for all I know) that was discovered to have stock in tobacco among other things. However, Mr. Drezner seems to have forgotten that 'Christian' does not automatically translate to 'Catholic'.
Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Read More
(6)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE