Monday, August 30, 2010 - 1:18 PM
I see that, over the weekend, Megan McArdle, Brad DeLong and Tyler Cowen all posted about stuff they've gotten wrong as bloggers. This is an excellent topic to post about. Bloggers are supposed to prvide real-time analysis on breaking events -- of course we're going to get a lot of stuff wrong. As Brad correctly notes:
f you don't mark your beliefs to market occasionally, and throw out worthless intellectual trash, you ossify--you become one of those demented old coots detached from reality ranting unintelligibly at the moon.
Looking back on my eighth (!!) year of blogging, here are the big things I think I got wrong over the past year:
1) The Green Movement did not cause Iran's regime to crack up. Score one for the Leveretts -- Iran's regime has effectively silenced the Green movement, without any visible internal cost. Indeed, the regime now seems entrenched enough so that the fundamentalists and conservatives can now ignore reformists and start turning on each other. I confess, I though the Ashura protests marked an inflection point on Iran. Nope. The regime has suffered some serious costs from its internal repression, but Khamenei ain't going anywhere anytime soon.
2) Iceland was willing to pay the price of financial isolation. I knew that Icelanders were outraged at the notion that they had to help bail out Icesave depositors in England and the Netherlands. I also thought, however, that when the question was put to a referendum, Icelanders would pause for a moment and consider the ramifications of financial isolation. Um... whoops.
3) The G-20 was been far less useful than I anticipated. A year ago at this juncture I was pretty pessimistic about the prospects of G-20 macroeconomic policy coordination. I was hopeful, however, that the G-20 could function effectively as a mechanism to pressure China into revaluing the yuan.
And... things are worse on both fronts than I anticipated. At Toronto, the G-20 encouraged contractionary fiscal policies way too early, helping to push the global economy into double3-dip territory. On the yuan, China has niminally pledged to let the yuan float, but acual movement has been pretty meager.
It only took me about 15 minutes to come up with this short list. I hereby invite and encourage all commenters to root through the archives to find other screw-ups.
For some unknown reason, I was looking down the long blogroll at "A Tiny Revolution" and when I saw your name under "Appreciated" I clicked it to see what you were up to. (I haven't been here since Feb) So I was very surprised to see your #1 admittance that you were wrong about an issue I called you on. Yeah for me!
However, even the wrongness you cite isn't the important way you were wrong. It was not just a prediction of what Ashura meant for the future of the Iranian regime - surely predictions are often wrong - but a factual one about the number and intentions of those protesting during that time. As the Leverettes pointed out in their comment, you had literally no evidence to back your claim that the Greens made up more than half of the Iranian population. That and realizing that the Green movement didn't want to overthrow the regime would have prevented you from ever making the wrong prediction in the first place.
Oh, and if you don't get many comments on this thread, don't take it as you were right about everything else, but as an indication as to how many people care.
Skipped a " mark in the link: Leverettes comment.
And if you wish to return the favor of finding fault, my blog is Norwegian Shooter
Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Read More
(2)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE