Monday, January 31, 2011 - 7:08 PM
Events in Egypt are now officially happening Too Fast to Blog About While Egyptians are Still Awake.
Sooo... in the meantime, I have a review of George Friedman's The Next Decade: Where We've Been... and Where We're Going in the latest issue of Texas Monthly. Friedman is the founder and CEO of Stratfor, which is based in Austin, Texas.
Here's how the review opens and closes:
As a rule, those who predict the future of world events should be viewed the same way Hermione Granger viewed Hogwarts’s divination classes—with unremitting skepticism. Social scientists may have something to offer in the way of explanation or short-term speculation, but there are serious limits to any kind of global soothsaying. World politics are simply too complex to forecast anything precisely in the medium term; it’s like asking a meteorologist to predict the weather a decade from now....
Perhaps I exaggerated Hermione’s skepticism of divination a bit. An otherwise stellar student, she was clearly frustrated that she was simply no good at it. Similarly, I should confess a smidgen of envy at Friedman’s conviction that he will be proved right about everything. Some writers are so sure of their beliefs that their assuredness has a viral quality, infecting the reader even if their logic fails. Friedman possesses that certainty in truckloads, and The Next Decade contains a few nuggets of insight as well. But make no mistake: Things will happen over the course of the next decade—and the next year and the next week—that will completely rock George Friedman’s world. (emphasis added)
Hey, are my predictive powers amazing or what??!! OK, those predictive powers were really the result of an excellent editor at Texas Monthly, but you get the idea.
I believe you can read the whole thing. Incidentally, his key insight into Egypt comes on page 92: "Even if the secular Nasserite regime fell, it would be a generation before Egypt could be a threat, and then only if it gained the patronage of a major power." Ah, that explains why Israel is handling these events so calmly. Oh, wait...
For a fun exercise, see if Friedman's current analysis jibes with how he predicts the next decade.
I like Friedman's boldness and willingness to be wrong, even very wrong. But at least he contributes some food for thought, even if it might have to be recalled from the shelf. His 1991 "The Coming War with Japan" always reminds me to salt heavily... http://www.amazon.com/Coming-War-Japan-George-Friedman/dp/0312058365.
The predictive "success" of the book is reflected by its current price: used copies are available on Amazon.com for as little as 1 cent, plus shipping.
Shoulda warned me about those man, you totally wrecked the ending. Also, good review although I'm sad that you didn't mention Friedman's provocative claim on Iran. Lastly, I ordered your book several days ago and should expect it in the mail soon.
The current events and coming events remind me of the line in the wizard of oz.."Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain"
This evolutionary change is part of the technoligical changes in communications, coupled with Wikileaks. When things get stripped back and things get exposed the truth comes forward. Sounds simple, but it is. Like the bank auditors show up and the embezzeling vp decides to confess. Where this ends up depends on the players and the politics. .
You don't have to agree with Friedman's opinion, but some of his predictions seem rational to me. At least he doesn't try to grab readers by riding the long-gone popular wave of zombies all the time... (sorry for that)
Well, point is that whatever transition comes to Egypt, it won't become a threat overnight. The term of a "generation" may be a long shot, but the country would need at least a couple of years to shape itself up. The Haaretz article you quoted reflects the Israeli concern about the immediate effect of the loosening grip of Egyptian power, namely the loosening of the Gaza blockade. While it may be uncomfortable for them, it can hardly be described as an outright threat. In order to pose a direct threat against the militarily superior Israel, Egypt would need to produce a Turkey-like stellar growth which is impossible without a strong, established, determined government which now seeks unlikely at best.
Daniel W. Drezner is professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Read More
(5)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE